Intramedullary Nailing Versus Plate Fixation for Humeral Shaft Fractures: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Document Type : SYSTEMATIC REVIEW

Authors

1 Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, Newark, NJ, USA

2 Department of Orthopedic Surgery, St. Luke’s University Health Network, Bethlehem, PA, USA

3 Drexel University, Philadelphia, PA, USA

Abstract

Background: The two techniques most utilized in the surgical treatment of humeral shaft fractures are open reduction 
internal fixation (ORIF) and intramedullary nailing (IMN). Although there have been multiple comparative clinical studies 
comparing outcomes for these two treatments, studies have not suggested one approach to be superior to the other. 
The purpose of this study is to perform a systematic literature review and meta-analysis of studies that evaluated the 
treatment of humeral shaft fractures with either ORIF or intramedullary nail.
Methods: We conducted this meta-analysis utilizing stricter inclusion and broader exclusion criteria to examine these 
two common approaches. We examined those articles which have compared first-time, closed fractures of the humeral 
diaphysis in adults in fracture patterns that could be treated equivalently by intramedullary nail or plate fixation. The 
primary outcome of interest was nonunion, and studies that did not report nonunion rates were excluded.
Results: There were a total of 1,926 abstracts reviewed and a total of three articles were included in the final analysis 
after screening. There was no significant difference in the incidence of nonunion between plating (2/111, 1.8%) and 
nailing (4/104, 3.9%) (P>0.05). The mean difference in average time to union for plated fractures and nailed fractures 
was 1.11 weeks (95% CI 0.82 to 1.40) which was statistically significant (P<0.05). There was a significant difference in 
the incidence of radial nerve palsy (12/111, 10.8%) for plating compared to nailing (0/104, 0%) (P=0.0004). There was 
no difference in incidence of post-operative infection between the two groups intramedullary nailing (P>0.05).
Conclusion: The results of this analysis demonstrate an increased risk of iatrogenic radial nerve injury, and a 
significantly shorter time to union when treating humeral shaft fractures with plating as compared to intramedullary 
nailing. There was no difference in the rates of nonunion or delayed union. Based on the evidence, both plating and 
nailing can achieve a similar treatment effect on humeral shaft fractures.
Level of evidence: II

Keywords

References

  1. Ekholm R, Adami J, Tidermark J, Hansson K, Törnkvist 
    H, Ponzer S. Fractures of the shaft of the humerus. An 
    epidemiological study of 401 fractures. J Bone Joint 
    Surg Br. 2006;88(11):1469-73. 
    2. Rose SH, Melton LJ 3rd, Morrey BF, Ilstrup DM, Riggs 
    BL. Epidemiologic features of humeral fractures. Clin 
    Orthop Relat Res. 1982;(168):24-30.
    3. Sarmiento A, Zagorski JB, Zych GA, Latta LL, Capps 
    CA. Functional bracing for the treatment of fractures 
    of the humeral diaphysis. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 
    2000;82(4):478-86. 
    4. Carroll EA, Schweppe M, Langfitt M, Miller AN, 
    Halvorson JJ. Management of humeral shaft fractures. 
    J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2012;20(7):423-33. 
    5. Koch PP, Gross DF, Gerber C. The results of functional 
    (Sarmiento) bracing of humeral shaft fractures. J 
    Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2002;11(2):143-50. 
    6. Wallny T, Westermann K, Sagebiel C, Reimer M, 
    Wagner UA. Functional treatment of humeral shaft 
    fractures: indications and results. J Orthop Trauma. 
    1997;11(4):283-7. 
    7. Ring D, Chin K, Taghinia AH, Jupiter JB. Nonunion after 
    functional brace treatment of diaphyseal humerus 
    fractures. J Trauma. 2007;62(5):1157-8. 
    8. Hosseini Khameneh SM, Abbasian M, 
    Abrishamkarzadeh H, Bagheri S, Abdollahimajd F, 
    Safdari F, et al. Humeral shaft fracture: a randomized 
    controlled trial of nonoperative versus operative 
    management (plate fixation). Orthop Res Rev. 
    2019;11:141-7. 
    9. Sterne JAC, Savović J, Page MJ, Elbers RG, Blencowe NS, 
    Boutron I, et al. RoB 2: a revised tool for assessing risk 
    of bias in randomised trials. BMJ. 2019;366:l4898. 
    10.Chiu FY, Chen CM, Lin CF, Lo WH, Huang YL, Chen 
    TH. Closed humeral shaft fractures: a prospective 
    evaluation of surgical treatment. J Trauma. 
    1997;43(6):947-51. 11.Rodrí�guez-Merchán EC. Compression plating versus 
    hackethal nailing in closed humeral shaft fractures 
    failing nonoperative reduction. J Orthop Trauma. 
    1995;9(3):194-7. 
    12.Wang C, Dai G, Wang S, Liu Q, Liu W. The function 
    and muscle strength recovery of shoulder after 
    humeral diaphysis fracture following plating and 
    intramedullary nailing. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 
    2013;133(8):1089-94. 
    13.Li Y, Wang C, Wang M, Huang L, Huang Q. Postoperative 
    malrotation of humeral shaft fracture after plating 
    compared with intramedullary nailing. J Shoulder 
    Elbow Surg. 2011;20(6):947-54. 
    14.Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG, PRISMA 
    Group*. Preferred reporting items for systematic 
    reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. 
    Annals of internal medicine. 2009;151(4):264-9.
    15.He SW, Qinruixian, Li B. Internal fixation of shaft 
    humerus fractures by dynamic compression plate 
    or interlocking intramedullary nail: a prospective, 
    randomised study. Biomedical Research - India. 
    2017;28(14):133-40.
    16.Rabari YB, Prasad DV, Somanni AM, Kumar P. 
    Comparative study of functional outcome of dynamic 
    compression plating with intramedullary interlocking 
    nailing in close fracture shaft of humerus in adults. 
    International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics. 
    2017;3(4):828.
    17.Zhao JG, Wang J, Meng XH, Zeng XT, Kan SL. Surgical 
    interventions to treat humerus shaft fractures: A 
    network meta-analysis of randomized controlled 
    trials. PLoS One. 2017;12(3):e0173634. Published 
    2017 Mar 23. 
    18.Qiu H, Wei Z, Liu Y, Dong J, Zhou X, Yin L, et al. A 
    Bayesian network meta-analysis of three different 
    surgical procedures for the treatment of humeral shaft 
    fractures. Medicine (Baltimore). 2016;95(51):e5464. 19.Kurup H, Hossain M, Andrew JG. Dynamic compression 
    plating versus locked intramedullary nailing for 
    humeral shaft fractures in adults. Cochrane Database 
    Syst Rev. 2011;(6):CD005959. Published 2011 Jun 15. 
    20.Zhao JG, Wang J, Wang C, Kan SL. Intramedullary nail 
    versus plate fixation for humeral shaft fractures: a 
    systematic review of overlapping meta-analyses. 
    Medicine (Baltimore). 2015;94(11):e599. 
    21.Dai J, Chai Y, Wang C, Wen G. Dynamic compression 
    plating versus locked intramedullary nailing 
    for humeral shaft fractures: a meta-analysis of 
    RCTs and nonrandomized studies. J Orthop Sci. 
    2014;19(2):282-91. 
    22.Ma J, Xing D, Ma X, Gao F, Wei Q, Jia H, et al. 
    Intramedullary nail versus dynamic compression 
    plate fixation in treating humeral shaft fractures: 
    grading the evidence through a meta-analysis. PLoS 
    One. 2013;8(12):e82075. 
    23.Liu GD, Zhang QG, Ou S, Zhou LS, Fei J, Chen HW, et 
    al. Meta-analysis of the outcomes of intramedullary 
    nailing and plate fixation of humeral shaft fractures. 
    Int J Surg. 2013;11(9):864-8. 
    24.Ouyang H, Xiong J, Xiang P, Cui Z, Chen L, Yu B. Plate 
    versus intramedullary nail fixation in the treatment of 
    humeral shaft fractures: an updated meta-analysis. J 
    Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2013;22(3):387-95. 
    25.Wang X, Chen Z, Shao Y, Ma Y, Fu D, Xia Q. A metaanalysis of plate fixation versus intramedullary 
    nailing for humeral shaft fractures. J Orthop Sci. 
    2013;18(3):388-97. 
    26.Hohmann E, Glatt V, Tetsworth K. Minimally invasive 
    plating versus either open reduction and plate 
    fixation or intramedullary nailing of humeral shaft 
    fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 
    randomized controlled trials. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 
    2016;25(10):1634-42. 
    27.Zhang Q, Sun N, Huang Q, Zhu S, Wu X. Minimally 
    Invasive Plating Osteosynthesis in the Treatment of 
    Humeral Shaft Fractures: A Meta-Analysis. J Invest 
    Surg. 2017;30(2):133-42. 
    28.Zheng X, Liu M, Duan X, Shu T, Xiang Z. Antegrade 
    locked intramedullary nailing versus dynamic 
    compression plating for humeral shaft fractures in 
    adults: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled 
    trials. European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & 
    Traumatology. 2012;22(6):443-7.
    29.Hu X, Xu S, Lu H, Chen B, Zhou X, He X, et al. Minimally 
    invasive plate osteosynthesis vs conventional 
    fixation techniques for surgically treated humeral 
    shaft fractures: a meta-analysis. J Orthop Surg Res. 
    2016;11(1):59. 
    30.Wang JP, Shen WJ, Chen WM, Huang CK, Shen YS, 
    Chen TH. Iatrogenic radial nerve palsy after operative 
    management of humeral shaft fractures. J Trauma. 
    2009; 66(3):800-3. 
    31.Streufert BD, Eaford I, Sellers TR, Christensen JT, 
    Maxson B, Infante A, et al. Iatrogenic Nerve Palsy 
    Occurs With Anterior and Posterior Approaches 
    for Humeral Shaft Fixation. J Orthop Trauma. 
    2020;34(3):163-8.
The Archives of Bone and Joint Surgery
Volume 10, Issue 8
August 2022
Pages 661-667

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 15 September 2021
  • Accept Date: 25 September 2021
  • First Publish Date: 03 October 2021

Share

How to cite

Statistics